Solved
How it was solved
Kenneth Robert Stough Jr. was arrested on November 2, 2021 and, after a five-day trial, was found guilty by an Orange County jury of first-degree murder with a weapon on August 25, 2023. He was sentenced to life in prison.
Read the full storySolvedMurder
The Beer Cans That Solved a 1996 Store Killing
Terence Paquette, 31, was found killed in 1996 in the Orange County, Florida, store where he worked overnight. DNA from beer cans led to Kenneth Stough, who was convicted of his murder in 2023.
- Where
- Lil' Champ convenience store, Clarcona Ocoee Road, northwest Orange CountyOrlando, Orange County, Florida
- When
- Solved August 25, 2023
- Case type
- MurderSolved case
- Agency
- Orange County Sheriff's Office, with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE)
The Story
On the morning of February 3, 1996, Terence Paquette, 31, the lone overnight clerk at a Lil' Champ convenience store on Clarcona Ocoee Road in northwest Orange County, was found killed inside the store. Investigators said the attacker had left his own blood at the scene, but the DNA did not match anyone in criminal databases, there were no witnesses, and the case went cold.
In 2019 the Orange County Sheriff's Office asked FDLE for help. FDLE contracted the Texas lab Othram to build a genealogy profile from the crime-scene DNA, and genealogists traced it to a family that pointed detectives toward a small group of brothers. One of them, Kenneth Robert Stough Jr., had once worked at the store and lived nearby. Detectives followed him and, investigators said, saw him throw away beer cans at a Lake County gas station. DNA from those cans matched the 1996 blood.
Stough was arrested in November 2021, more than 25 years after the killing. In August 2023, after a five-day trial, an Orange County jury found him guilty of first-degree murder with a weapon, and he was sentenced to life in prison.
Why it stands out
A 25-year-old case with the killer's blood at the scene but no database match, cracked when genetic genealogy pointed to a family and detectives collected beer cans he threw away at a gas station.
Small numbers show the source of each fact. Tap one to see it.
Timeline
Terence Paquette is found killed inside the Lil' Champ store where he worked the overnight shift.24
The case is re-examined; DNA testing excludes earlier persons of interest but no match is found.1
The Orange County Sheriff's Office asks FDLE for help; FDLE contracts Othram for genealogy-grade DNA testing.1
Key Facts
What is known for sure, each checked against a source.
- Investigators said the attacker's blood was found throughout the store, but it had no database match for 25 years.2
- Genetic genealogy narrowed the search to a family of brothers; Stough had worked at the store and lived nearby.2
- Detectives obtained his DNA from beer cans he threw away at a Lake County gas station.25
- Stough was convicted of first-degree murder with a weapon and sentenced to life in prison.34
- News outlets spell the victim's first name Terence, Terrence or Terrance; Terence Leslie Paquette is used here as reported at sentencing.4
Questions still open
What nobody has answered yet. Talk it through with other readers.
Question 1
Investigators have not publicly detailed a motive for the 1996 robbery and killing.
Discuss this question
Chenzo Clues
Details I noticed by putting the public records side by side. Observations, not accusations and not police findings.
Clue 1 added October 7, 2026
He was opening the store, not working overnight
Our summary calls him the lone overnight clerk, but two sources say something different. Othram's case write-up says he arrived between 5 and 6 a.m. to get ready for a 6 a.m. opening and was killed within a few hours. WFTV calls him the store manager and says he was getting ready to open for the day. Othram also notes he'd moved to Orlando only a few years earlier and worked 60-hour weeks.14
How I found it: Compared how Othram, WFTV and NBC News each describe his job and the time of the attack.
Clue 2 added October 7, 2026
One bloodstain on a freezer handle did it
When you line up the timeline, the case was actually closed in 1997, reopened in 2003, and the DNA went into the FBI's CODIS database with no match. The break came from a bloodstain on a freezer handle in the store. FDLE explained that a vendor turned the sample into a data file that was uploaded to two public genealogy sites, Family Tree and GEDmatch, and the family tree pointed to one of three brothers.24
How I found it: Combined the FDLE statements quoted by NBC News in 2021 with WFTV's 2023 account of the case history.
Clue 3 added October 7, 2026
Three versions of where the beer cans came from
NBC's 2021 arrest story says detectives watched Stough throw away beer cans at a Lake County gas station. WFTV in 2023 says they had put a GPS tracker on his car and saw him toss a bag of cans into a public dumpster in Eustis. NBC's 2023 verdict story says the cans were picked up outside his home in Eustis, and it also dates the arrest to March 2021, while the other sources say early November 2021. The trial record would settle it.234
How I found it: Compared the arrest and DNA-collection details across the three news reports.
Photos & Video
Case Details
- Case number
- No public case number
- Investigating agency
- Orange County Sheriff's Office, with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE)
- Classification
- Murder · Solved case, solved August 25, 2023
- Location
- Orlando, Orange County, FLLil' Champ convenience store, Clarcona Ocoee Road, northwest Orange County
- Date
- People named in public records
- Terence Leslie Paquettevictim, age 31
- Kenneth Robert Stough Jr.convicted, age 56
- Last verified
Sources
5 verified public sources from NBC News, Othram / DNASolves, WFTV Channel 9 and 1 more publisher.
Official records: 1Databases: 1News coverage: 3
Official records (1)
- 5Sheriff Mina update on 1996 Cold Case Murder (video)Orange County Sheriff's Office (YouTube), November 2021
Databases (1)
- 1FDLE and Orange County Sheriff's Office Team with Othram to Identify Suspect in the 1996 Murder of Terrence PaquetteOthram / DNASolves, November 2021
News coverage (3)
- 2DNA on beer cans leads to arrest in 1996 cold case murder in FloridaNBC News, November 2021
- 3Florida man linked to 1996 cold case killing by beer cans is convictedNBC News, August 2023
- 4Florida man sentenced for brutal murder that went unsolved for decadesWFTV Channel 9, August 27, 2023

