Know something about this case?
Tips go directly to Flagler County Sheriff's Office. Chenzo Cases does not receive tips. You can usually stay anonymous.
Reward: Anonymous tips through Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida may be eligible for a cash reward.
More ways to reach investigators
- Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida (anonymous)1-888-277-8477Tip page on westopcrime.com
Emergency? Call 911.
UnsolvedUnsolved murder
Who Killed Bruce McPhail?
Bruce McPhail was found murdered in the Intracoastal Waterway near Flagler Beach in 1997. He had no name for almost 26 years until DNA identified him in 2023, and his murder is still unsolved.
- Where
- Intracoastal Waterway near the old Sea Ray canal (Sea Ray Drive area)Flagler Beach, Flagler County, Florida
- When
- 29 years ago
- Case type
- Unsolved murderOpen case
- Agency
- Flagler County Sheriff's Office
The Story
On the morning of Sept. 10, 1997, workers testing a boat spotted a man's body in the Intracoastal Waterway near the old Sea Ray canal in Flagler Beach. Investigators said he had been bound, stabbed several times and shot before he ended up in the water. Nothing on him gave a name, and for almost 26 years he was known only as an unidentified white male, with a 1997 facial approximation as the only picture of what he might have looked like.
Flagler County's Cold Case Unit, created in 2020, sent his remains to Othram, a Texas forensic lab, in 2021. DNA sequencing and genetic genealogy led detectives to his name, which the Sheriff's Office announced in August 2023: Robert McPhail, 58, who went by his middle name, Bruce. He came from the Kenora and Winnipeg area of Manitoba, Canada, and had moved to South Florida in the mid-1990s. Detectives said he had no known connection to Flagler County.
A day after his name was released, someone who had known him in South Florida sent the Cold Case Unit a photo of him from the 1980s. The Sheriff's Office says the case is still an open homicide and that the people who knew Bruce in South Florida in the 1980s and 1990s may hold the information needed to learn who killed him and why.
Small numbers show the source of each fact. Tap one to see it.
Timeline
Workers testing a boat spot a man's body in the Intracoastal Waterway near the old Sea Ray canal in Flagler Beach. The FCSO dive team recovers him.134
Forensic artist Betty Pat Gatliff (Skullpture Inc.) produces a facial approximation, the only image of the unknown man for 26 years. He is entered in NamUs as UP3055.56
Investigators tell the Palm Coast Observer that analysis suggested the man may have been of Eastern European descent with costly European dental work.7
Sheriff Rick Staly creates FCSO's first dedicated Cold Case Unit.8
His remains are sent to Othram for forensic-grade genome sequencing and genetic genealogy.35
FCSO announces the man has been identified as Robert "Bruce" McPhail, 58, of the Kenora/Winnipeg area of Manitoba.1345
A person who knew him in South Florida provides the Cold Case Unit with a photo of him from the 1980s.16
On the 27th anniversary, the case is reported as still unsolved and actively investigated.9
Still listed by FCSO as an unsolved homicide with an open tip form.12
Key Facts
What is known for sure, each checked against a source.
- Investigators said he was bound, stabbed multiple times and shot.13
- He was identified 26 years later through DNA and investigative genetic genealogy performed by Othram.35
- He went by his middle name, Bruce, came from the Kenora/Winnipeg area of Manitoba, Canada, and moved to South Florida in the mid-1990s.13
- Detectives said he had no known connection to Flagler County.4
- After his name was released, a person who knew him in South Florida sent FCSO a photo of him from the 1980s.16
- His 1997 description estimated a white male aged 30 to 50; he was actually 58.53
- According to the detective who reopened the case, the two Sea Ray workers first noticed an alligator in that stretch of the waterway, and then saw him.17
- Investigators believe he had been killed about a week before he was found.17
- He was never reported missing. He was an only child, his parents died in the 1970s, and distant relatives lost touch after he moved to Florida in the mid-1990s.17
- His financial and court records stop in 1997, which helped confirm the identification.17
- The original 1997 lead detective, Richard Brendel, kept detailed notes that the Cold Case Unit relied on decades later.17
- In August 2023 the Sheriff's Office Cold Case Unit had 21 cold cases, four of them unidentified people, and started with the unidentified ones.17
- Family planned to lay him to rest with his parents, who were from Winnipeg.17
Questions that remain
What nobody has answered yet. Talk it through with other readers.
Question 1
Why was a man from South Florida, with no known ties to Flagler County, in the Intracoastal near Flagler Beach in September 1997?
Discuss this questionQuestion 2
Who knew Bruce McPhail in South Florida in the 1980s and 1990s, and when was he last seen there?
Discuss this questionQuestion 3
FCSO says he moved to South Florida in the mid-1990s, yet the photo sent in was taken in South Florida in the 1980s. What was his history in Florida before the move?
Discuss this question
Chenzo Clues
Details I noticed by putting the public records side by side. Observations, not accusations and not police findings.
Clue 1 added October 7, 2026
The old listing called him a likely local man
Before he had a name, the Doe Network listing (built from NamUs and Florida records) said the best leads suggested he was a local man. After the 2023 identification, detectives said Bruce had no known connection to Flagler County. The same old listing gives details I did not see on the FCSO page: he was found near Marker 11 in the Intracoastal, about 60 feet off an undeveloped shoreline, under medical examiner case 97-23-251.134
How I found it: Pulled the archived Doe Network entry for the 1997 Flagler Beach John Doe and compared it with 2023 coverage of the identification.
Clue 2 added October 7, 2026
A boat in both records
The pre-2023 listing says investigators believed he was taken by boat to the spot where he was found. Othram's 2023 identification update describes Bruce as passionate about boats, and places the recovery northeast of the old Sea Ray Boats plant at 100 Sea Ray Drive, now Boston Whaler. FCSO has asked anyone who knew him in South Florida in the 1980s and 1990s to come forward.13141
How I found it: Read the archived unidentified-person listing next to Othram's identification update.
Clue 3 added October 7, 2026
Reward quoted at up to $9,500
Our case page only says Crime Stoppers tips may earn a reward. The 2023 identification notice put a number on it: up to $9,500 for anonymous tips through Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida. In 2020 FCSO's release quoted up to $5,000 for unsolved cases, so Crime Stoppers is the place to confirm the current amount.14812
How I found it: Compared the reward wording in the 2023 Othram/FCSO notice and the 2020 FCSO release.
Clue 4 added October 7, 2026
One of three Flagler cases in seven weeks of 1997
Bruce was found on Sept. 10, 1997. Ten days later Robert Picard was reported missing from the Mondex area west of Bunnell, with signs of foul play in his home, and on Oct. 29 Andrea Ford was found shot beside SR 100. All three are still open FCSO files. The Sheriff's Office has not said these cases are connected.11516
How I found it: Sorted the Flagler County cases in this database by date and checked each against its FCSO cold case page.
Photos & Video
Official releases and openly licensed files, credited. Tap a photo to see it larger.
Photo credits and sources
- 1. Robert "Bruce" McPhail, as pictured on the FCSO cold case file (FCSO says a 1980s photo of him was provided by someone who knew him in South Florida) Photo released by the Flagler County Sheriff's Office on its cold case page · Official release
- 2. FCSO Cold Case Unit case card for Robert McPhail (case #97-21613) Flagler County Sheriff's Office · Official release
Chenzo Cases · Episode 1
He Had No Name for 26 Years. Then DNA Found Him.
Out now on Chenzo Cases
Watch Episode 1Outside coverage and documents
Linked, not copied. These open on the publisher's site.
- The 1997 facial approximation used for 26 years (shown on Othram's case page)Photo · Facial approximation by Betty Pat Gatliff / Skullpture Inc., released by FCSO; page by Othram
Case Details
- Case numbers
- 97-21613FCSO cold case
- UP3055NamUs UP
- Investigating agency
- Flagler County Sheriff's Office
- Classification
- Unsolved murder · Open case
- Location
- Flagler Beach, Flagler County, FLIntracoastal Waterway near the old Sea Ray canal (Sea Ray Drive area)
- Date
- People named in public records
- Robert "Bruce" McPhailvictim, age 58
- Reward
- Anonymous tips through Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida may be eligible for a cash reward.
- Last verified
Sources
17 verified public sources from Flagler County Sheriff's Office, Othram / DNASolves, Palm Coast Observer and 7 more publishers.
Official records: 7Databases: 2News coverage: 7Community: 1
Official records (7)
- 11997 McPhail (Cold Case #97-21613)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
- 2Cold Case Unit (unsolved cases index)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
- 8News Release #192: FCSO Launches Cold Case Unit to Reexamine Unsolved Crimes (archived copy)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 12, 2020
- 11Submit a Crime TipFlagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
- 12Crime Tips (Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida, 1-888-277-TIPS, westopcrime.com)Volusia Sheriff's Office
- 151997 Picard (Cold Case #97-23163)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
- 161997 Ford (Cold Case #97-25596)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
Databases (2)
- 5Flagler County Sheriff's Office identifies Robert Bruce McPhailOthram / DNASolves, August 17, 2023
- 14Flagler County John Doe identified as Robert Bruce McPhail (update)Othram / DNASolves, August 17, 2023
News coverage (7)
- 3Man found murdered in ICW in Flagler County identified 26 years laterNews4Jax, August 17, 2023
- 4Sheriff's office identifies Flagler Beach cold case homicide victim (Daytona Beach News-Journal)Daytona Beach News-Journal via Yahoo News, August 17, 2023
- 6Cold case homicide victim identified after 26 yearsPalm Coast Observer, August 17, 2023
- 7In From the ColdPalm Coast Observer, September 15, 2012
- 927 years later, Robert Bruce McPhail's murder remains unsolved in FloridaTampa Free Press, September 10, 2024
- 10McPhail identified (FlaglerLive)FlaglerLive, August 17, 2023
- 17Remains of Winnipeg man murdered in Florida identified 26 years laterCBC News Manitoba, August 18, 2023
Community (1)
- 133597UMFL - Unidentified Male (archived Doe Network listing, last updated 3/28/21)The Doe Network (Internet Archive copy), March 28, 2021
