
Know something about this case?
Tips go directly to Flagler County Sheriff's Office. Chenzo Cases does not receive tips. You can usually stay anonymous.
Reward: Anonymous tips through Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida may be eligible for a cash reward.
More ways to reach investigators
- Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida (anonymous)1-888-277-8477Tip page on westopcrime.com
Emergency? Call 911.
UnsolvedUnsolved murder
Who Killed Dennie Cayton?
Dennie Cayton, 60, was found dead behind his home in Palm Coast in January 2013. Investigators say he was killed inside the home weeks earlier, and his murder is still unsolved.
- Where
- Marsh area behind his home on Covington LanePalm Coast, Flagler County, Florida
- When
- 13 years ago
- Case type
- Unsolved murderOpen case
- Agency
- Flagler County Sheriff's Office
The Story
On Jan. 11, 2013, the body of Dennie Keith Cayton, 60, was found in a marshy area behind his home on Covington Lane in Palm Coast. The Medical Examiner ruled his death a homicide by stabbing. Because of the condition of the remains, a formal identification took months and relied on an examination by the University of Florida's anthropology section; his name was released in June 2013.
Investigators believe he was killed inside his home around Dec. 17, 2012, nearly four weeks before he was found, and that his body was then moved outside. Detectives said no motive had been established and that they believed someone in the community had information.
When FCSO created its Cold Case Unit in 2020, Cayton's case was one of the first it took up. The Sheriff's Office said evidence had been sent for additional DNA processing and that cellular data was being re-examined by its Digital Forensics Unit.
Small numbers show the source of each fact. Tap one to see it.
Key Facts
What is known for sure, each checked against a source.
- Investigators believe he was killed inside his home around Dec. 17, 2012, and his body was moved outside.1
- The Medical Examiner ruled the death a homicide by stabbing.23
- Identification took months and relied on an osteological examination by the University of Florida.23
- Detectives said in 2014 that no motive had been established.3
Questions that remain
What nobody has answered yet. Talk it through with other readers.
Question 1
Who saw or spoke with Dennie Cayton in mid-December 2012?
Discuss this questionQuestion 2
Why did nearly four weeks pass before anyone found him?
Discuss this questionQuestion 3
What will the newer DNA processing and the re-examined phone data show?
Discuss this question
Chenzo Clues
Details I noticed by putting the public records side by side. Observations, not accusations and not police findings.
Clue 1 added October 7, 2026
The timeline in days
When you count it out, about 25 days passed between the date investigators think he was killed (around December 17, 2012) and the day he was found (January 11, 2013). His name wasn't released until June 24, 2013, roughly six months after his death.12
How I found it: Counted the days between the dates on the sheriff's case page and the 2013 identification report.
Clue 2 added October 7, 2026
Three detectives in the public record
The 2013 report names Detective Annie Conrad, the 2014 anniversary appeal names Detective Nate Koep, and the case was reopened in 2020 by Detective Andrew Cangialosi, the agency's first full-time cold case detective. Tips today go through the main FCSO line or Crime Stoppers.234
How I found it: Compared the contacts listed in each official appeal from 2013 to 2020.
Clue 3 added October 7, 2026
The reward has stayed at $5,000
Every appeal I found, in 2013, 2014 and 2020, offers the same thing: anonymous tips through Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida at 888-277-TIPS can earn up to $5,000.234
How I found it: Checked the reward wording in each appeal.
Photos & Video
Official releases and openly licensed files, credited. Tap a photo to see it larger.

Photo credits and sources
- 1. Dennie Cayton, as pictured on the FCSO cold case file Photo released by the Flagler County Sheriff's Office on its cold case page · Official release
- 2. FCSO Cold Case Unit case card for Dennie Cayton (case #13-2503) Flagler County Sheriff's Office · Official release
Outside coverage and documents
Linked, not copied. These open on the publisher's site.
- FCSO news release #192 (Oct. 12, 2020) announcing the agency's first Cold Case Unit and the cases it reopenedDocument · Flagler County Sheriff's Office
Case Details
- Case number
- 13-2503FCSO cold case
- Investigating agency
- Flagler County Sheriff's Office
- Classification
- Unsolved murder · Open case
- Location
- Palm Coast, Flagler County, FLMarsh area behind his home on Covington Lane
- Date
- People named in public records
- Dennie Keith Caytonvictim, age 60
- Reward
- Anonymous tips through Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida may be eligible for a cash reward.
- Last verified
Sources
8 verified public sources from Flagler County Sheriff's Office, Palm Coast Observer, AskFlagler and 1 more publisher.
Official records: 5News coverage: 3
Official records (5)
- 12013 Cayton (Cold Case #13-2503)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
- 4News Release #192: FCSO Launches Cold Case Unit to Reexamine Unsolved Crimes (archived copy)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 12, 2020
- 6Cold Case Unit (unsolved cases index)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
- 7Submit a Crime TipFlagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
- 8Crime Tips (Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida, 1-888-277-TIPS, westopcrime.com)Volusia Sheriff's Office
News coverage (3)
- 2BREAKING: Body identified in Covington Lane murderPalm Coast Observer, June 24, 2013
- 3Help police solve 2013 Covington Lane murderPalm Coast Observer, January 17, 2014
- 5The Cold Cases of Flagler County: A Look at the Unsolved CrimesAskFlagler, May 7, 2026



