Chenzo Cases. home page Sign in
Andrea Ford, as pictured on the FCSO cold case file

Know something about this case?

Tips go directly to Flagler County Sheriff's Office. Chenzo Cases does not receive tips. You can usually stay anonymous.

Reward: Anonymous tips through Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida may be eligible for a cash reward.

More ways to reach investigators

Emergency? Call 911.

UnsolvedUnsolved murder

Andrea Ford: One Gun, Two Unsolved Murders

  • Andrea Ford
  • Bunnell, Florida

Andrea Ford was found shot beside a road in rural Bunnell in 1997. Investigators say the same gun killed Dawn Petterson in Palm Coast in 1999, and both murders are still unsolved.

Where
Roadside near State Road 100 and County Road 302Bunnell, Flagler County, Florida
When
29 years ago
Case type
Unsolved murderOpen case
Agency
Flagler County Sheriff's Office

The Story

On the morning of Oct. 29, 1997, Andrea Ford, who also went by Andrea Daniluk, was found on the side of the road near State Road 100 and County Road 302 in rural Bunnell. Investigators said she had been shot in the back of the head. She was from the Daytona Beach area.

Nearly two years later, on Sept. 8, 1999, Dawn Petterson, also from the Daytona Beach area, was found shot the same way beside a road in Palm Coast. The Flagler County Sheriff's Office says the investigation found that the same gun was used in both killings. Neither case has been solved.

When FCSO launched its first Cold Case Unit in 2020, the Ford and Petterson killings were among the first cases it reopened. The Sheriff's Office said biological evidence from both was being evaluated for DNA testing that did not exist in the 1990s. Detectives are asking anyone who knew Andrea, or knew who she spent time with in the fall of 1997, to come forward.

Small numbers show the source of each fact. Tap one to see it.

Timeline

  1. Andrea Ford is found on the roadside near SR 100 and CR 302 in Bunnell with a gunshot wound to the back of the head.14

  2. Dawn Petterson is found shot beside a road in Palm Coast. Investigators later determine the same gun was used in both killings.12

  3. FCSO's new Cold Case Unit lists the Ford and Petterson killings among its first reopened cases; biological evidence is evaluated for new DNA analysis.3

  1. First Coast News revisits the linked cases.4

  2. The Florida Sheriffs Association's Cold Case Florida podcast features both cases.5

  3. Still listed by FCSO as an unsolved homicide.17

Key Facts

What is known for sure, each checked against a source.

  • She was found Oct. 29, 1997, on the roadside at SR 100 and CR 302 in Bunnell, shot in the back of the head.1
  • FCSO says the same gun was used in the 1999 murder of Dawn Petterson (FCSO case #99-22207), also unsolved.12
  • FCSO's 2020 release identifies her as Andrea Ford, also known as Andrea Daniluk.36
  • She was from the Daytona Beach area.1
  • Evidence from both cases was evaluated for DNA testing that did not exist in the 1990s.3

Questions that remain

What nobody has answered yet. Talk it through with other readers.

  1. Question 1

    Who saw Andrea Ford in the hours before she was found on Oct. 29, 1997, and how did she get from the Daytona Beach area to rural Bunnell?

    Discuss this question
  2. Question 2

    What happened to the gun that FCSO says was used in both the Ford and Petterson killings?

    Discuss this question
  3. Question 3

    Did anyone know both women?

    Discuss this question

Chenzo Clues

Details I noticed by putting the public records side by side. Observations, not accusations and not police findings.

  1. Clue 1 added October 7, 2026

    "Same gun" today, "similar ballistics" in 2020

    The Sheriff's Office case pages for Andrea and for Dawn Petterson now both say the same firearm was used. The October 2020 news release that launched the Cold Case Unit worded it more carefully: both women were shot with firearms "sharing similar ballistic characteristics." FCSO is the agency that could say what changed between the two descriptions.312

    How I found it: Compared the archived 2020 FCSO news release #192 with the current Ford and Petterson cold case pages.

  1. Clue 2 added October 7, 2026

    Two roadsides about seven miles apart

    I mapped both documented spots. The intersection of SR 100 and CR 302 west of Bunnell and the corner of Squash Blossom Trail and Seminole Woods Boulevard in Palm Coast are about 7 miles apart in a straight line, roughly 8 miles by road. Both women were from the Daytona Beach area, and the two scenes are about 27 and 19 road miles from downtown Daytona.1210

    How I found it: Placed the intersections named on the FCSO case pages on OpenStreetMap and measured straight-line and OSRM driving distances.

  2. Clue 3 added October 7, 2026

    Fall 1997 in this database: three Flagler cases in seven weeks

    When you line up the Flagler cases on this site, Andrea's is the third FCSO cold case file from a seven-week stretch in fall 1997. An unidentified man, later named as Bruce McPhail, was found in the Intracoastal on Sept. 10, Robert Picard of the Mondex area was reported missing Sept. 20 with signs of foul play at his home, and Andrea was found Oct. 29. FCSO has only linked Andrea's case to Dawn Petterson's; it has not said these 1997 cases are connected.11112

    How I found it: Sorted the Flagler County cases in this database by date and checked each against its FCSO cold case page.

  3. Clue 4 added October 7, 2026

    The reward has been quoted at different amounts

    The 2020 release said anonymous Crime Stoppers tipsters could be eligible for up to $5,000 on unsolved Flagler cases. When Bruce McPhail was identified in 2023, the tip notice for that case quoted up to $9,500. The Ford case page does not list an amount, so Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida is the place to confirm what applies today.3139

    How I found it: Compared the reward language in the 2020 FCSO release with the 2023 McPhail identification notice.

See Chenzo Clues from every case

Photos & Video

Official releases and openly licensed files, credited. Tap a photo to see it larger.

Andrea Ford, as pictured on the FCSO cold case fileTap to enlarge
Andrea Ford, as pictured on the FCSO cold case filePhoto released by the Flagler County Sheriff's Office on its cold case page · Official release

Photo credits and sources

  1. 1. Andrea Ford, as pictured on the FCSO cold case file Photo released by the Flagler County Sheriff's Office on its cold case page · Official release
  2. 2. FCSO Cold Case Unit case card for Andrea Ford (case #97-25596) Flagler County Sheriff's Office · Official release

Outside coverage and documents

Linked, not copied. These open on the publisher's site.

Case Details

Case number
  • 97-25596FCSO cold case
Investigating agency
Flagler County Sheriff's Office
Classification
Unsolved murder · Open case
Location
Bunnell, Flagler County, FLRoadside near State Road 100 and County Road 302
Date
People named in public records
  • Andrea Ford (also known as Andrea Daniluk)victim
Reward
Anonymous tips through Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida may be eligible for a cash reward.
Last verified

Sources

13 verified public sources from Flagler County Sheriff's Office, First Coast News, Florida Sheriffs Association and 4 more publishers.

Official records: 9Databases: 2News coverage: 2

Official records (9)

  1. 11997 Ford (Cold Case #97-25596)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
  2. 21999 Petterson (Cold Case #99-22207)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
  3. 3News Release #192: FCSO Launches Cold Case Unit to Reexamine Unsolved Crimes (archived copy)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 12, 2020
  4. 5Cold Case Florida podcast, Episode 3: The Murders of Andrea Ford and Dawn PettersonFlorida Sheriffs Association, December 4, 2024
  5. 7Cold Case Unit (unsolved cases index)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
  6. 8Submit a Crime TipFlagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
  7. 9Crime Tips (Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida, 1-888-277-TIPS, westopcrime.com)Volusia Sheriff's Office
  8. 111997 Picard (Cold Case #97-23163)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026
  9. 121997 McPhail (Cold Case #97-21613)Flagler County Sheriff's Office, October 7, 2026

Community Discussion

  • Not a police tip line. Police don't read these posts. Contact investigators with real information.
  • Don't name anyone as a suspect unless police or prosecutors have.
  • Stick to public information and say when something is a rumor.

Join the conversation

No account needed. Any name works.

Want your avatar and rank on your posts? Become a Gumshoe (free) or sign in.

Loading comments...

    Discussion rules

    1. Tips go to police, not here.
    2. No naming uncharged people as suspects. Those posts come down.
    3. No harassment of families, witnesses or anyone else.
    4. Public facts only, and say when something is a rumor.
    5. No graphic images or descriptions.

    Posts are public and moderated. Use Report on anything that breaks the rules. Full details in the content policy.

    More cases like this

    • UnsolvedUnsolved murder

      Who Killed John Stubbs?

      John Robert Edward Stubbs

      Bunnell, Florida ·

      John Stubbs, 46, was found dead with gunshot wounds behind a home in Bunnell the day after Thanksgiving in 2015. No arrest has been made, and his murder is still…

    • UnsolvedUnsolved murder

      What Happened to George Contos?

      George Contos

      Bunnell, Florida ·

      George Contos, 58, was reported missing from his home west of Bunnell in 2015, and his car was found days later in Palm Coast. Investigators believe he was killed, but…

    • UnsolvedUnsolved murder

      Who Killed Dennie Cayton?

      Dennie Keith Cayton

      Palm Coast, Florida ·

      Dennie Cayton, 60, was found dead behind his home in Palm Coast in January 2013. Investigators say he was killed inside the home weeks earlier, and his murder is still…

    Search Chenzo Cases